Search NextJob for answers
Is reservation a fundamental right in India UPSC?
However, the Supreme Court pointed that a writ petition under Article 32 of the Constitution can be filed only in case of violation of fundamental rights. The Court observed that the Right to Reservation is not a fundamental right.
Is reservation necessary in India Group Discussion?
Reservation is a problematic approach because it promotes the idea that for one section to prosper the other section needs to be put down. This policy has not succeeded in uplifting backward groups. Instead, it has created more rifts among the sections of society.
Is the policy of reservation justified in India?
Since caste system has kept downtrodden people oppressed and depressed, it needs to be the cause of their elevation to the mainstream of the society. Thus, caste based reservation is justified. As it has been rightly pointed out by Dr. B.R.
Is reservation allowed in UPSC?
Ans. In the UPSC CSE 2021, about 105 were reserved for SC candidates and about 60 seats were reserved for ST candidates. As per the policies of the Government of India, SC candidates are provided with a 15% reservation and ST candidates are provided with a 7.5% reservation.
What are 2 reasons when reservations might be necessary?
More Predictable Wait Times A reservation system helps businesses optimize restaurant seating layouts, so that they can accommodate more customers and give guests more accurate wait times. If the wait becomes longer than anticipated, the host can adjust expectations and offer a complimentary snack or beverage.
Why is reservation necessary?
Reservations in India were introduced: To rectify the past and historical injustice against the backward classes in India. To ensure that equal representation can be seen from people belonging to all castes in the services under the state and centre. To provide an equal platform for everyone irrespective of their caste.
What is the main aim of reservation?
The primary objective of the Indian reservation system is to enhance the social and educational status of underprivileged communities and thus improve their lives.
Is reservation against right to equality?
Sometimes, it is necessary to give special treatment to a few underprivileged people – it ensures that the backward classes also get equal opportunities. Therefore, reservations are not against the right to equality, rather they help in ensuring right to equality.
Why reservation is not a fundamental right?
The Supreme Court, relying upon Ajit Singh v. State of Punjab 2, opined that Article 16 (4) and Article 16 (4-A) of the Constitution were in the nature enabling provisions, where discretionary powers were vested with State Governments to consider providing reservations.
Why was the reservation policy a failure?
The reservation system was a disaster for the Indians as the government failed to keep its promises. The nomadic tribes were unable to follow the buffalo, and conflict among the tribes increased, rather than decreased, as the tribes competed with each other for fewer resources.